Boom
Reef blocks and winches installation design
As you remember I made 4 reefs on my new main sail, and 4-th i would likely never use ;)
I tried to calculate what could be loads in reef lines on my boat and get really surprised numbers.
My sail:
| Configuration | Luff remaining | Estimated area | Full-sail area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full sail | 11.14 m | 25.60 m² | 100% |
| Reef 1 | 9.45 m | 19.2 m² | 75% |
| Reef 2 | 7.80 m | 13.6 m² | 53% |
| Reef 3 | 6.13 m | 8.8 m² | 34% |
| Reef 4 | 4.46 m | 4.9 m² | 19% |
At fourth reef set, about 4.9 m² of mainsail remains exposed to the wind.
At a worst-case wind speed of 60 knots, that sail area produces approximately 3.7 kN force.
If about 40% reaches the reef clew, the clew must take 1.5 kN. Because the two reef-line legs pull at a shallow angle of about 10°, each leg carries approximately (1.5 ÷ [2 × \sin(10°)] = 4.3) kN. Allowing a 50% increase for gusts, flogging and shock x1.5 = 6.4 kN. so, a reef block i need for about 8 kN working load.
The same logic calculation gives us about the same loads on all reefs.
| Reef | Sail area | Maximum wind | Total sail force | Normal line tension | Peak line tension |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reef 1 | 19.2 m² | 20 kn | 1.62 kN | 1.86 kN | 2.80 kN |
| Reef 2 | 13.6 m² | 30 kn | 2.58 kN | 2.97 kN | 4.45 kN |
| Reef 3 | 8.8 m² | 40 kn | 2.97 kN | 3.42 kN | 5.13 kN |
| Reef 4 | 4.9 m² | 60 kn | 3.72 kN | 4.29 kN | 6.43 kN |
6kN if about 350lb, no way to pull it by hands, so I need to have winches to be able to set right tension.
BUT, with reasonable use winch must not exceed MWL for lines and construction.
so, I selected #10 winches with "reasonable high" cranking force person may do is 70lb with x10 advantage 700lb. So, we good here.
Next challenge - curvature of the boom. I would need curvature following spacers to install the blocks and winches.
So far I am looking to use 3D printed ASA plastic with 100% infill to make them. 3D-printed ASA spacers is what I can match the boom’s curvature instead of trying to force a flat block onto a curved surface. With 100% infill and about 2,400 mm² of support area, even approximately 12 kN of total screw-clamping force creates only around 5 MPa of average pressure. ASA can comfortably support this.
From inside, washers would concentrate the load around four small spots risk of make dents local cracking. The full size backing plate ties all four M5 screws together and spreads the pulling and twisting forces across the complete mounting area.
Plastic also has some plasticity and able to form better connection between spacer and boom surface.
In short words.
I install blocks and winches to the mast using 3D printed spacers to follow boom curvature and distribute load. ASA plastic calculated like good enough material for this. Back side is I will need to make sure i will retight screws several times after installation.
Spacers for the block.
External
One side of the spacer is flat, other following boom surface. Also spacer is asimetrical to install one block 10mm higher than boom equator and other 10mm lower to let reef lines closer to boom end go freely without touching other reef block.
Internal
from inside the boob another spacer installed to align backing plate be in parallel with the block.
Backing plates are 3mm SS304 flat steel with tapered holes. center hole is to put screw to keep plate on the spacer.
Winch spacers.
External.
Internal
Backing plates are 5mm SS. small screws keep plate at place.
Boom disassembly process
In dreams all looks well ontill some stuburn screw appeared to stuck.
I think engineers who use slotted round-head screws in places where they can seize have a special place in hell.
Disassembling was relatively simple with help of impact screwdriver, BUT one from 20 screws made me more problems than all other together!
After several times screw bit jumped out of screw and scratchcard my hands I realized why you will not find slot screwdriver bits for impact screwdriver. They just jump out and injury your hands.
What i did - I put a nut with hole a size of screw head diameter. and tie it to boom with duct tape!
then easy undo this screw without any risk on screwdriver jump out of slot.
| Bastard in hands. |
Boom is stripped.
Reason why i stripped it is simple - I need to put backing plates inside the boom and screws sticking inside are not helping any.
Blocks installation.
Drill holes
Backing plate
Apply tefgel on the screw and aluminum holes and install the block! is it look nice?
Then two winches
Backing plates, same approach.
Boom coning back.
Starboard side Reef1 and Reef3 (reef1 block I left original) |
| Port side Reef2 and Reef4 blocks, outhaul line on the top. |
Winch and cleat for reefs on the each side on the boom.


Comments
Post a Comment